A weighty book, profoundly dark. I wouldn’t want to find myself in such a Petersburg. Sonia’s fate is regrettable. Marmeladov, on the other hand, evokes no sympathy; there have been and still are many drunkards in Russia. I’ve personally faced this problem and know how challenging it is to quit. I like Razumikhin; not everyone would go to such lengths for another person.

The murder of the old woman is a heavy and senseless scene. Such is life. The emotions of an ordinary person, rather than a hardened criminal, are portrayed exceptionally well. As I read further, I grew to appreciate the book more. It’s not just about the crime itself. I used to perceive it solely from the standpoint of the crime and its subsequent punishment. But now, I see more clearly that it’s a book about an idea that can lead to crime. This book is about people. Svidrigailov is unquestionably a negative character, yet he has done numerous good deeds. Sonia is trapped in destitution and a difficult life. Raskolnikov only awakens in the epilogue, finding salvation in Sonia.

The book concludes, leaving the feeling that one should continue with “The House of the Dead.” It all makes sense.

It’s an excellent book, but far from suitable for everyone and not at every age.

Finished: September 2023

Rating: 10